The health of a population provides another lens through which to examine value placed on human life by a government. All indices of health correlate positively with measures of justice. For example, members of Rule of Law abiding societies must be guaranteed "equal treatment and absence of discrimination" (Subfactor 4.1) and, Subfactor 4.2, "the right to life". Such individuals should be expected to have free access to health care and preventive health measures and enjoy long life, as a result. 

To test this hypothesis one would examine reported data on population health status (e.g. Infant mortality, life expectancy, etc.) compare them to adherence to Rule of Law factors. Attempts to accomplish this are thwarted by the fact that health data are typically aggregated for a population and rarely  stratified even on the basis of simple demographic characteristics. It may be possible to view data about certain health conditions for males vs. females; for members of certain ethnic/racial groups and, possibly, for different age groups.

This homogenized approach, however, prevents us from looking at sub-sets. For example, the infant and child mortality rate is higher for girls than boys in India, especially those whose mothers experienced intimate partner violence (1). This is a good example of violation of Subfactors 4.1 and 4.2 that would be missed if only published homogenized health data are reported. In addition, especially in countries with repressive governments, it is difficult to adequately examine the health status of other subsets of the population, particularly, the most disenfranchised. Because they must depend on others to represent their needs and advocate for their receipt of health care,  groups that include prisoners, homeless people, the elderly and even children are at increased risk for poor health.  Their health problems are often lost in aggregated data bases of reported indices of health.

On April 7, World Health Day, we should dedicate ourselves anew to advocating for access to high quality preventive and health care services for all and transparency in reporting health data for all segments of the population, particularly the most vulnerable.

Reference:

Gender-based disparities in infant and child mortality based on maternal exposure to spousal violence: the heavy burden borne by Indian girls. Silverman JG, et al.

Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2011 Jan;165(1):22-7. doi: 10.1001/archpediatrics.2010.261."

 

Iris F. Litt The Clayman Institute for Gender Research

Through her work on young women's health issues, Dr. Iris Litt has helped to revolutionize the care of women in prisons and juvenile detention centers. For the past twenty-five years her research has focused on health problems of adolescents, including substance abuse, prevention of pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases, and most recently, the long-term consequences of eating disorders in adolescent women.

Dr. Litt has commented that her early interest in adolescent health led her to help improve health care delivery in prisons and juvenile detention facilities. With her mentor, Dr. Michael I. Cohen, she wrote an article in the American Journal of Public Health in 1974 advocating for the right to quality medical care for adolescents in prison. She continues to promote this issue and to study the physician's role in treating adolescents and has written several articles on this topic over the years.

Among many honors accorded her, Dr. Litt was elected to the Institute of Medicine in 1995, received the annual Outstanding Achievement Award in Adolescent Medicine from the Society for Adolescent Medicine in 1992, and in 1996 was listed in Best Doctors in America. As editor-in-chief of the Journal of Adolescent Health, Litt is also a frequent contributor; in a 2002 editorial, she addressed the issue of bioterrorism and adolescents.

 
title bar

Read More

title bar
Press release

WJP Rule of Law Index 2024 Press Releases

We create a press release for every country considered in the WJP Rule of Law Index, available in different languages. To find a specific press release, go to the relevant region and select the country of interest from the drop-down menu. For press inquiries please contact us at [email protected]

Read More
Press release

The U.S. Now Ranks 43rd on Election Confidence

Released today, the annual World Justice Project (WJP) Rule of Law Index® evaluates a wide variety of rule of law indicators in 142 countries and jurisdictions. Two weeks out from the 2024 election, the U.S. ranking on the Index sub-factor that measures confidence in elections has dropped from 37th to 43rd globally.

Read More