Scott Fulton with Steve Wolfson
US Environmental Protection Agency

Last summer I addressed the World Justice Forum on the importance of effective environmental governance; this was part of a robust conversation about the rule of law and its role in governance.  This conversation has been steadily gaining momentum over the last year and has led to an explicit recognition of the core elements of effective environmental governance, as well as growing momentum for initiatives to enhance cooperation to strengthen environmental governance in countries around the world.

Implementation of national environmental protections as well as international environmental goals and treaty obligations depends on effective environmental governance at the national level. In an article I co-authored last year with the Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Antonio Benjamin, we outlined some of the thinking that has evolved over the last 3-4 decades on effective environmental governance. 

We have now begun to see convergence around the key elements of effective governance systems; these elements were highlighted recently by a document developed out of The World Congress on Justice, Governance and Law for Environmental Sustainability, a side event to the U.N. Rio + 20 Conference on Sustainable Development that convened more than 200 high-level judges, prosecutors, auditors, and other legal experts. 

More information on this meeting is available here.

This consensus arrives at five foundational elements of effective governance.

  1. Environmental laws that are clear, implementable and enforceable;
  2. Meaningful public engagement, including: public access to environmental information, the opportunity for participation in environmental decision making, and access to justice;
  3. Accountability and integrity, from the individual level to the institutional level;
  4. Effective institutional arrangements between and within governmental entities involved in environmental protection; and
  5. Provision for fair and responsive resolution of environmental disputes, principally through the courts.

These elements come together to combine to form an integrated and self-reinforcing system.They are the essential building blocks that lay a foundation to support the successful implementation of environmental protections everywhere.

A floor that -

  1. Rests upon the rule of law,
  2. That makes environmental information the primary language of environmental protection,
  3. That guarantees participation in environmental decisions by all those affected by those decisions,
  4. That ensures true accountability by government and industry alike,
  5. That eliminates institutional inefficiency and confusion, and
  6. That brings swift and meaningful justice to environmental grievances and disputes.

As we continue this dialogue, efforts to strengthen environmental governance can be more effective and efficient if we engage in cooperative efforts including through new forum to work together to strengthen environmental governance. We can see this work gaining momentum:

  1. The World Bank’s global forum on law, justice and development includes a working group on environment and natural resources law.
  2. The World Justice Project is working to incorporate environment into its Rule of Law Index®.
  3. UNEP, the UN Institute for Training and Research, and the World Resources Institute are expanding efforts to implement principle 10 of the Rio Declaration.

These and other initiatives reflect the growing momentum for new partnerships and initiatives to strengthen environmental governance and provide opportunities to enhance cooperative efforts to strengthen environmental governance  by promoting information-sharing, strengthening links, and fostering collaboration.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comments:

Thank you for your efforts in these important matters. I ask you to never lose site of the fact that sustainability and corruption cannot co-exist.  I believe that all efforts to promote and support sustainability must have strong anti-corruption components to be successful. Your work with the new regime in Tunisia, in coordination with WFEO, shows the importance of anti-corruption programs in all development, but especially sustainable development.

Regards,
Bill Henry

William P. Henry, P.E.

President.2005.American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)

Chair, 2006, American Association of Engineering Societies (AAES)
[email protected]

Scott Fulton with Steve Wolfson US Environmental Protection Agency

Scott Fulton was nominated by President Obama to serve as the General Counsel of the US Environmental Protection Agency in May 2009, and was confirmed by the Senate on August 7, 2009. He has served as an environmental prosecutor and Assistant Chief in the Department of Justice, Environment and Natural Resources Division, where he contributed to the development of many of the liability principles that underpin the United States’ environmental protection program. He has also served as Director of Civil enforcement and subsequently as Principal Deputy Assistant Administrator in EPA's enforcement program, as a Judge on EPA's Environmental Appeals Board, and as Deputy Assistant Administrator and Acting Assistant Administrator in EPA’s Office of International Affairs where he led EPA’s international environmental policy development and program implementation and represented the United States in various international settings and negotiations.

Steve Wolfson is a senior attorney with the International Law Group of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of General Counsel, where he coordinates OGC's international capacity building activities on environmental law. Steve has participated in international environmental treaty negotiations and dispute settlement proceedings, and has taught International Environmental Law as an adjunct professor at Howard University School of Law and Comparative U.S.-Chinese Environmental Law as an adjunct professor at the Vermont Law School Environmental Law Center summer session.

title bar

Read More

title bar
Alejandro Gonzalez Arreola addresses a panel of experts at WJP Mexico's Open Justice Metric launch

The World Justice Project (WJP) is pleased to announce that WJP Mexico Country Office Director Alejandro González Arreola has been named the global organization’s next Chief Engagement Officer. In his new Washington-D.C.-based role, Alejandro will build, strengthen, and support WJP’s global network of rule of law stakeholders; lead global policy engagement, advocacy initiatives, and campaigns on rule of law topics; and spearhead WJP’s work to advance the rule of law through strategic convenings, including the World Justice Forum.  

Read More
Image from "Ruby's Story" on the International Justice Mission's website

The International Justice Mission (IJM) uses the World Justice Project Rule of Law Index in their work to end modern-day slavery. During the 2023 Index launch, Samson Inocencio, IJM’s regional vice president for Asia Pacific, joined other leaders to explain how. We spoke further with him to learn how the rule of law and the Index help IJM fight violence against people living in poverty. 

Read More